Explanation
Alternation between a strong, difficult-to-defend thesis and a weaker, easier-to-defend version. When faced with criticism, a position retreats to a secure core and then returns unnoticed to the broader claim.
Example
Atlas example: When faced with criticism, a position retreats to a secure core and then returns unnoticed to the broader claim.
Counterexample
Mere similarity in form without the relationship characteristic of Motte-and-Bailey.
Distinction
Distinguishing from equivocation: The decisive factor in Motte-and-Bailey is the specific movement: a position retreats into a safe core when faced with criticism and then returns unnoticed to the broader assertion.
Effect on thought and perception
A position retreats to a secure core in the face of criticism and then returns unnoticed to the broader claim.
Resonance
Motte-and-Bailey renders the relationship perceptible as a directed transformation: a position retreats into a secure core when faced with criticism and then returns unnoticed to the broader claim.
Cite this entry
Reich, Michael (Hrsg./ed.): „Motte-and-Bailey“. Atlas der Sprache, AT-119-037. ATLAS 251, data model 1.6.0. https://atlasoflanguage.com/concept/AT-119-037The address remains stable; editorial content may evolve. A verified modification date per entry is not yet available. Include your access date for precise references.