Explanation
Reconstruction of an opposing position in its strongest and most plausible form. Understanding becomes a prerequisite: The opposing position is first given the best viable form before criticism begins.
Example
Atlas example: Understanding becomes a prerequisite: The opposing position is first given its best viable form before criticism begins.
Counterexample
Mere similarity in form without the relationship characteristic of steelmanning.
Distinction
Distinguishing from the straw man: What is decisive in Steelmanning is the specific movement—understanding becomes a prerequisite: the opposing position is initially given the best viable form before criticism begins.
Effect on thought and perception
Understanding becomes a prerequisite: The opposing position is first given the best tenable form before criticism begins.
Resonance
Steelmanning renders the relationship perceptible as a directed transformation: Understanding becomes a prerequisite: The opposing position is first given the best tenable form before criticism begins.
Cite this entry
Reich, Michael (Hrsg./ed.): „Steelmanning“. Atlas der Sprache, AT-119-038. ATLAS 251, data model 1.6.0. https://atlasoflanguage.com/concept/AT-119-038The address remains stable; editorial content may evolve. A verified modification date per entry is not yet available. Include your access date for precise references.