ATLAS OF LANGUAGE

Contextual explanation · NAV-G01-040

Shaming

This explanation addresses the term in its originating context. It is not an additional canonical Atlas profile.

Explanation

Shaming is treated here as a communicative act that devalues someone before others or in relation to their self-image. Its intended effect need not occur. In the link from chleuasmos, mockery may be a means; shame as a feeling and shaming as an action remain distinct.

Movement of thought

1. Identify target and audience. 2. Specify the norm of recognition at stake. 3. Identify the verbal means. 4. Separate intention from observed response. 5. Examine consequences for participation.

Example

After an innocent question, an invented chair remarks publicly, “Surely everyone here already knows that.” The put-down goes beyond answering.

Counter-test

A factual correction in private is not automatically shaming merely because it identifies an error.

Scientific use case

Interaction analysis can examine audience, disparagement and subsequent responses.

Effect

Participants may withdraw or resist the devaluation.

Resonance

Another person's judgement may reverberate within one's self-image.

Distinction

Distinguish guilt, criticism and shame; an emotion must not be attributed without evidence.

Sources